Trevor Burnham

Sure, it works in practice…

Entries Tagged as 'tv'

Kings: A Libertarian Reading

January 16th, 2010 Comments Off

You might not have heard of the short-​​lived NBC drama Kings. It’s a modern retelling of the rise of David from humble Goliath-​​slayer to majestic ruler, but that’s not impor­tant. What’s impor­tant is the sheer pleasure of seeing a world much like our own, in terms of tech­nol­ogy and culture, that’s geopo­lit­i­cally stuck in the Old Tes­ta­ment. Picture The West Wing, but with the lovably pres­i­den­tial Martin Sheen replaced by a ruthless, theo­cratic dictator, King Silas, bril­liantly por­trayed by Ian McShane.

As with Deadwood, Ian McShane alone makes the series worth watching. But there’s some­thing else that struck me after a few episodes. If there is a message to the series, it’s this: Everyone loves King Silas for the occa­sional mercy that he shows. (Most acutely, we learn in episode six that there’s an annual holiday, “Judgment Day,” on which the king hears exactly ten appeals from the lower courts.) To us, the sophis­ti­cated, democracy-​​loving viewers, this is obvi­ously absurd: Why should the king get credit for rec­ti­fy­ing injus­tices that he merely restrains himself from com­mit­ting? And yet, any gov­ern­ment, even an elected one, is subject to this same paradox. Having an unques­tion­able king is just the extreme case.

I can’t say for sure whether King Silas is intended to be the complex, con­flicted, sinister yet sym­pa­thetic per­son­i­fi­ca­tion of “Big Gov­ern­ment.” But it’s cer­tainly possible to inter­pret him that way. Ayn Rand could learn a thing or two from Kings.

Tags: